Page 10, 9th May 2008
Page 10
Report an error
Noticed an error on this page?If you've noticed an error in this article please click here to report it.
Tags
Share
Related articles
The Society Of St Pius X Is In Schism With
Lefebvrists Face Crisis As Bishop Is Exposed As...
Like The Sspx, The Pope Is Worried By The Devastation Of...
Benedict Xvi Has Removed The Raison D'être Of The Sspx
Rome Gives Lefebvrists A Deadline For Unity
It is no secret that the SSPX disagrees with Vatican
II — yet dialogue with Rome continues From Mr Norman Calvert SIR — It has never been a secret that the Society of St Pius X has indicated its disagreement with some aspects of Vatican II ("Lefebvrists snub Pope's call for unity". April 25). Collegiality, ecumenism and religious liberty are three of these. The postconciliar popes and Vatican authorities have always been aware of this, unlike, it seems, The Catholic Herald.
The .society welcomed the Mom Proprio of Pope Benedict but has always made the valid point, confirmed by a commission of cardinals in 1986, that the Mass of Pius V had never been abrogated and that priests were entitled to celebrate using that form. The Church granted permission for something which had never been forbidden in the first place.
You may disagree with the views of the society but should be prepared to examine its case, which has always been given in a rational manner, unlike your editorial. The Vatican authorities do not share your acerbic views, and dialogue continues.
Yours faithfully.
NORMAN CALVERT Middlesbrough, North Yorkshire
blog comments powered by Disqus