Page 3, 3rd May 2002

3rd May 2002

Page 3

Page 3, 3rd May 2002 — BY CHRISTINA WHITE
Close

Report an error

Noticed an error on this page?
If you've noticed an error in this article please click here to report it.

Tags


Share


Related articles

A Traditionalist Goes Over The Top

Page 9 from 17th May 2002

Heritage Focus On Reordering

Page 3 from 7th October 1994

Reordered Cathedral Rededicated

Page 3 from 19th May 1995

Cafod: Setting The Record Straight

Page 7 from 10th May 2002

Bishop Plans Reordering Of Leeds Cathedral

Page 2 from 27th July 2001

BY CHRISTINA WHITE

PARISHIONERS unhappy at the reordering of their churches have a new organisation to give public expression to their anger and fight their cause.
Ouch! — Outcry Against Ugly Churches — launched by the Catholic writer and journalist Moyra Doorly this month aims to reclaim the sacred spaces of churches and to deter parish priests from insensitive modernisations.
The society's first bulletin has been sent to every diocese in England and Wales with a plea to priests to "end the disaster — reclaim sacred space". Miss Doorly maintains that contemporary church design is based on modernist principles which are relativist, rather than religious.
"With all distinctions diminished, the impression is of homogeneity and lack of direction ... it says: 'There is nothing special here'," she writes.
She insists that modern church buildings deny the "transcendent" and no longer point to a heaven that is beyond.
Miss Doorly advocates returning church buildings to their original form, ending the modern practice of the priest facing the people.
But Canon Alan Griffiths, a member of the heritage committee of the bishops' conference of England and Wales, was unmoved by pleas for a return to pre-Vatican II practice.
He said: "I think that the lady will find, if she looks in the revised Roman Missal, an express commendation of Mass to be celebrated facing the people wherever possible. Perhaps that is something she might like to note."
Miss Doorly is currently preparing an "Ouch! manifesto" to guide her campaign against the brutal ugliness of much modern church building. It is unlikely to find favour with modernists.
Architect Austin Winkley, who has undertaken hundreds of church reordering projects, described the campaign as "mischievous".
He said: "I think this is an old-fashioned view and I find very little common ground with these people.
"They express a vague spirituality that is common to them and not to anyone else. I rapidly lose patience with the preaching mentality that goes with it. I think it's just mischievous."




blog comments powered by Disqus