Page 4, 29th June 1990

29th June 1990
Page 4
Page 4, 29th June 1990 — Irrelevance of all apparitions
Close

Report an error

Noticed an error on this page?
If you've noticed an error in this article please click here to report it.

Tags

Locations: Grangetown

Share


Related articles

Bishop Orders Seers To End 'apparitions'

Page 4 from 14th July 2006

Medjugorje Visionaries Celebrate Anniversary

Page 4 from 29th June 2001

Visions Disputed

Page 1 from 22nd June 1990

Vatican Will Reject Medjugorje, Says Bishop

Page 4 from 6th June 2008

Basis Of Criteria In Judging Apparitions

Page 4 from 7th September 1984

Irrelevance of all apparitions

YOUR front page report on apparitions in Galway (June 22) reinforces a prejudice I have always held against these alleged manifestations of the Virgin Mary. The two "seers", SallyAnne and Judy Considine seem to see Our Lady wherever they go. You report that they have seen her not only in Galway but in Wexford, Grangetown and Mayfield. The Virgin is cropping up more often than the Queen Mother.

When will the church realise that the individual hallucinations of no doubt wellmeaning people like these sisters

are of no importance whatsoever in our struggle to live out Christ's gospel. Be it Medjugorje, Lourdes, F' :ima or wherever, what those who troop there in great numbers are seeking is proof. and that is the one thing that Christianity cannot in any form provide. It is a question of faith. Obsession with apparitions undermines the whole basis of Christianity and leads to the current ludicrous situation in Galway.

It is no good the church authorities picking and choosing which apparition they wish to endorse. They should either give fre rein to whoever thinks they have seen Our Lady and to pilgrims who want to go there, or they should issue a once and for all authorative statement saying that "signs and wonders" are an irrelevance to contemporary Christianity.

As it is now we are falling between two stools and Christian witness in a challenging and complex modern world is left open to question when for many believers the sum total of their faith is to go in search of a

proof. Steven Wright Redruth, Cornwall




blog comments powered by Disqus