Page 4, 27th November 1981

27th November 1981
Page 4
Page 4, 27th November 1981 — Still on the subject of omissions ...
Close

Report an error

Noticed an error on this page?
If you've noticed an error in this article please click here to report it.

Tags

Locations: Jerusalem, Florence

Share


Related articles

The Very Mystery Of Which Walsingham Holds The Secret

Page 4 from 13th November 1981

Avoiding The Hidden Perils Of The Most Popular Hymns

Page 12 from 10th September 1999

Well-produced Hymnal Reviewed By

Page 6 from 18th February 1972

Purgatory's Pain A Common Point

Page 4 from 24th February 1989

And The Church

Page 3 from 5th February 1960

Still on the subject of omissions ...

FURTHER to Fr Richer on the omission of the verses about purgatory from all the current Catholic Hymnals, Nov 13. how many other people have noticed a significant scriptural omission from the present Lectionary.

I refer, of course, to the passage from II Macchabees 12, dealing with the collection of silver being sent to Jerusalem that sacrifice might be offered for the sins of the dead.

This text was familiar in all old catechetical books as an OT "proof' of the teaching of the Councils of Florence and Trent: that purgatory exists and that the souls can be aided by our prayers.

Considering the wide scope of Sacred Scripture that is contained in the Lectionary, and furthermore that this was one of the rare passages from the OT occuring in the 1570 Missal (second Mass of All Souls' Day), would it be too much to assume that this passage was deliberately omitted by those who prepared the Lectionary? And if so, why?

Michael S. Feben

Church of the Annunciation Charminster Rd, Bournemouth




blog comments powered by Disqus