Page 6, 23rd December 1983

23rd December 1983

Page 6

Page 6, 23rd December 1983 — Exclusion of women and social conventions
Close

Report an error

Noticed an error on this page?
If you've noticed an error in this article please click here to report it.

Tags


Share


Related articles

Women Priests

Page 4 from 9th December 1983

Women's Ordination?

Page 4 from 6th November 1992

Women In The Church

Page 5 from 18th February 1977

More Physical Than Spiritual

Page 4 from 30th May 1980

00 0° Priests:

Page 6 from 16th February 1968

Men And Women Should Know Their Place

Page 7 from 24th September 1965

Exclusion of women and social conventions

HOW on earth can Kevin O'Donnell, Dec 9, or anyone else know with certainty that Our Lord's not including women among the Apostles was merely due to the social conventions of the time?
What if He had, in fact, quite deliberately excluded women from such offices on principle and not just because of "prudent practicality?"
The tenor of the New Testament taken as a whole appears at least as capable of supporting this alternative interpretation of Our Lord's behaviour, as one that sees it as purely fortuitous, and this view has been upheld by the unanimous consent of Catholic Christianity in all ages.
Odd sectarian groups of course, have had women "celebrants" of their Eucharists, but mainstream orthodox Christianity has always reprobated them, firstly, as delirious enthusiasts, this despite
the fact that it could well be argued that the social conventions of the GraecoRoman world would have easily allowed for Christian women priests, since priestesses — the proper term for such ladies — were well known in their contemporary paganism, and no doubt the lack of their Christian equivalent stopped, in Mr. O'Donnell's phrase, many enlightened second century people from listening to the Christian message.
Moreover, it is disingenuous to quote Galatians 3:28, "in Christ there is neither Jew nor Greek, male or female", as an argument in favour of women priests.
It has nothing to do with that matter, but rather is a testimony to the truth that all human beings, whatever their condition, have equal access to God through Christ in baptism. William Tighe Cambridge




blog comments powered by Disqus